Monday, July 02, 2012

Methods and methodology, questions and answers

Academics and journalists frequently cite peer-reviewed studies as though the peer-review process warrants validity, which indeed it's meant to do. However, when a report or research is cited, knowing the methodology and in fact the basic research question and frame is crucial to determining which question or questions are being answered.

For example, anthropologist Douglas Fry (2005) looked through the literature in his field to inquire after the basic question: Which societies operate without war or with very rare examples of war? What he found was a welter of answers, but most of them were to slightly or even completely different questions, yet those studies were often cited as 'proof' that most, or even all, human societies are warlike and the few that weren't either were still violent or not worth mentioning.

But upon examining those cited studies, he found problems and this should encourage all of us to go deeper when we are citing any report or study--or when one is cited that seems to 'prove' that peace and justice are either a poor idea or impossible to achieve.

For instance, when one study 'proved' that just a small handful of societies have never had or almost never had wars, they dropped 61 cultures from the study because of insufficient data. This should beg the question, well, why might there be insufficient data? Could it be because, in fact, those societies--or at least some, probably most, if not all--don't go to war? As Fry points out, that might not be a flaw in the methodology because the study was asking about war and not the absence of war, that study has been cited to prove something that it does not prove. Fry and others have begun a serious catalog of what societies might actually show us that peace is possible.

Whether we are using the best science to make our point or whether we are reading someone else's use of 'evidence,' we should be aware of the limitations of all research, in addition to the value of it.

References

Fry, D. P. (2005). The human potential for peace: An anthropological challenge to assumptions about war and violence. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Sunday, July 01, 2012

Chickens and eggs: Hatching what comes naturally

Anthropologists who worked with two villages in Mexico--San Andres and La Paz--consistently found that there are higher levels of violence in San Andres than in La Paz. The adults have a higher rate of violence, and the children in both villages mirror the behavior of the adults (Fry, 2005). Is violence in children and adults "just natural"? Yes. Is nonviolence in adults and children "just natural"?

Yes.

What is most natural of all is the self-replication of behavior from one generation to the next. Children have always tended to emulate their parents and always will. Obviously, there are many individual exceptions to this tendency, but very rare exceptions at the group generality level. While aphorisms and 'common sense' should tell us that what we model for our children is what they will copy, actual science is also helpful because 'common sense' tells many people that smacking their children is how the children learn respect, learn to mind, learn to behave. Science can help us parse common sense from everyday foolishness.

Social norms can change faster than behavior--e.g., social norms have changed dramatically, thankfully, since my childhood, on spousal violence, but the social practice of wife-beating is not yet ended, sadly. The reverse is also true. When the law changed in many places on domestic violence, the social norms of the police officers who enforced the new and better laws often lagged far behind. So which comes first, new behavior or new norms, new laws or new practices? Clearly, that depends.

The easiest shift from childhood cultural influences, of course, is immersion in another culture. While some individuals resist changing to adapt and emulate new cultural values and practices, many follow the new herd in which they find themselves. As an inmate, I've seen this happen to those who "didn't belong in jail" in the sense that clearly, their values were not typical of the average inmate upon arrival, but I've seen them immersed in a new "moral Maytag" for even a week and shift behavior downwards in response. Soon they regard women, people of different ethic groups, or anyone not adequately represented in the inmate population as objectified others and the pejorative labels appear, used until challenged (which, as an older inmate with less malleable characteristics, was my self-appointed role).

This also applies in reverse. Most people suddenly immersed in a culture of better (more just, more accepting, less violent) values will usually begin to manifest at least verbal, then behavioral, agreement with those values (though they may retain plenty of vestigial inner doubts and objections). This is why successful campaign for social change argue not for a change in values, but for better cultural enforcement of the values you want them to believe they already hold. Of course we are all for peace, and here is one way we can help it arrive more quickly. Naturally we want a culture that is friendly and open and fair to all, and here is one thing we can do toward our common goal.

Nature or nurture? Yes. We are in a dialectical relationship with our own DNA, we create self-replicating generations and self-fulfilling prophesies all the time. Intervening in this is difficult and required if we want to shift our culture to peace, justice, and nonviolence. We can nurture our new nature but that takes courage and discipline. Fortunately, we can also nurture our natural courage and discipline until it produces the world we want.

References

 Fry, D. P. (2005). The human potential for peace: An anthropological challenge to assumptions about war and violence. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Saturday, June 30, 2012

Production, reproduction, and consumption

Historian William Hardy McNeill (1984) noted that when humankind formed the first standing armies in the prehistoric Middle East we saw the first class of macroparasite, since the armed forces produce nothing and simply consume (and when military hawks then become politicians, the phenomenon compounds, as we see when John McCain leads the charge against reduction of Pentagon oil consumption). However, some claim now that the aggression of warriors makes them reproduce more effectively than the rest of us males. The aggressors, they assert, are better at attracting women, siring children, and out-populating the peace-oriented males (Ghiglieri, 1999).

As someone who tried to think about this 44 years ago when the Ehrlichs' book, The Population Bomb, was published and when I read it at the ripe old age of 17, I will say that trying to outreproduce anyone seems particularly insane, given our stressed out resource base and scarcity of so much in the near future. Some of us would love to see the ancient forests remain and a bit of clean water remain drinkable.

Nonetheless, it is of interest to respond to these claims, backed up by 'research' done with highly flawed methodology in at least some cases. For instance, a world-famous study on the Yanomamo tribespeople--a particularly warlike hunter-gatherer society in Amazonia--purports to show that violence-committing males have more children than those who neglect to murder others. The astonishing omission from the discussion of validity of the study is that, on average, those males who hadn't committed murder were approximately a decade younger than the males who had killed someone. In any random population of human males younger than old age, obviously, a cohort of males some 10 years older will have more children. The Yanomamo study proves nothing about killing as a reproductive strategy (Fry, 2005).

This question is really only important insofar as the myth that war is inevitable and even desirable because we are driven to it by the evolutionary success of warring societies. There is just enough truth in that to be very dangerous indeed. It is reminiscent of Kurt Vonnegut's anecdote about another author asking him if Slaughterhouse Five was an antiwar novel (Ringler, 1993). When Vonnegut said yes, the fellow said, well, you might as well write an anti-glacier novel, by which he meant that war was just a force of nature, absolutely unavoidable (and now that a consuming war machine has helped to produce the global warming that is eradicating glaciers the irony is hard to miss).
The US is better at making war than any other culture ever has been in human history and we flatter ourselves constantly that we are the most successful culture on Earth too. As with most factors that relate to war, this is true in a narrow sense and for a short time.

We are in fact the best ever at amassing material goods, consumer items, and we have the huge homes, credit card debt, and storage facilities to prove it. We are awash in junk, degrading in every way. That, presumably, is success.

Here comes China. They manufacture everything and now finally outproduce the US in greenhouse gas, though the US still consumes more oil than any nation. Even though China has not been at war nearly as much as the US has, they certainly have out-reproduced the US, with almost four times the population. That is smart evolutionary strategy?

So what the war anthropologists are saying, presumably, is, have more war, have more children, and you have out-evolved those stupid peaceful ones. Thank goodness for the social scientists and peace researchers who have looked more deeply at these issues. Peace will prevail, as one organizer once told me, or it won't matter anyhow, because no one will be around to worry about it. Some day, in the not-so-distant future, we are going to have to relearn what the peaceful Stone Age tribes knew thousands of years ago, about how to live happily rather than so competitively, about how to relax and enjoy simple, beautiful pleasures rather than strive to make enough money to purchase the perennially elusive material possession that brings happiness, an illusion that endangers all of us, and being more warlike won't get anyone success in solving those problems.

References

 Fry, D. P. (2005). The human potential for peace: An anthropological challenge to assumptions about war and violence. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Ghiglieri, M. P. (1999). The dark side of man: Tracing the origins of male violence. Reading, MA: Perseus.


McNeill, W. H. (1984). The pursuit of power. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Ringler, Dick (Ed.) (1993). Dilemmas of war and peace: A sourcebook. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin-Extension.