Saturday, October 19, 2013

Nonviolent energy

Is there any relationship between the energy sources used by society and strategic nonviolence? That seems dubious, perhaps, to an average citizen who has no particular feelings about either, who pays no attention to either, and who neither seeks nor finds much information about either. Nonviolence? Most think Gandhi and King, quaint, from different times. Energy is just what we need to keep us moving along and we want it at a low price. Yes, there are some news stories about some controversies around energy issues, but the mainstream citizen is primarily regarded as a consumer first, a voter second, and in neither case is it in the interest of the elite-owner one-percent class to have the average person know much about either energy or nonviolence.

In his 2012 book, The Race for What's Left: The Global Scramble for the World's Last Resources, Michael Klare (p. 10) frames the picture as the elites and the captains of society might see it, that only scientists are warning about dire environmental consequences associated with fracking, tar sands, and other complex energy extraction technologies. The powerful people want it to happen. It all spells profit.

So how is that connected to strategic nonviolence?

Nonviolence, as understood by average folks and indeed many campaigners, is a moral witness, a personal obstruction of a morally objectionable practice, offered in resistance, based in conscience, unattached to results. The lack of attachment to results is a self-protective stance that helps activists avoid burnout as they lose again and again. But strategic nonviolence offers a way out of the hopelessness that informs the nonattachment by providing a different framework that resets the posture of strong campaigners toward victory.

Nonviolence was used again and again to oppose nuclear power, across the US and the world. It won sometimes and lost sometimes. The stories of victory, such as the shutdown of the Trojan nuclear power plant in Oregon, stand in contrast to the stories of defeat, such as Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant, despite strong nonviolent opposition--even including the 1981 nonviolent civil resistance that resulted in a record 1,900 arrests.

Now we see much more nonviolent opposition to hydrocarbon extraction, transport, and burning. This is mostly related to the science that proves the anthropogenic causation of global warming and climate chaos. So we see hundreds arrested starting in 2011 in opposition to the Keystone XL pipeline, arrests in Michigan, Washington DC and other tar sands actions.
But will this nonviolent struggle win or lose? If all those arrests didn't stop Diablo Canyon, what needed to be different? How can climate change activists win now?

As we try to integrate the theory and practice of conflict resolution into strategic nonviolence we can see a strengthening of both and that more robust practice can help design a more winning series of campaigns. Some of the elements:
  • Use nonviolent resistance as a BATNA, a best alternative to a negotiated agreement, which means that you constantly ask to negotiate. This is in stark contrast to many years of civil resistance offered as an end in itself. Get to the table. Develop a dialog, a partnership, with your adversary. Talk is cheap and cheap is good when you create your cost-benefit analysis, isn't it?
  • Design each campaign to be winnable in months, not years or decades. The goals that take longer are movements. Long campaigns usually suffer recruitment losses and success gets elusive. Winnable means reducing the stated immediate goal, increasing capacity, or both. Winning in increments is ultimately faster than losing big for long periods.
  • Develop multiple prongs. Speakers should be educating the public in any available venue. Lawyers should be filing briefs, lawsuits, and motions. Entertainers should be holding benefits to raise consciousness and resources. Citizens and professional organizers should be lobbying elected officials. Media workers should be flooding mainstream, alternative, and social media platforms with information. Volunteers should be phone banking and canvassing door-to-door. Officials should be called upon to hold public hearings and organizers should hold them if politicians or agency people won't. Start letter writing and petition campaigns. Push push push in all arenas.
Victory is totally possible and totally depends on "the people." The elite absolutely rely on maintaining that false image of a bubble of invincibility. Pop it. Show yourself and others that you have an alternative form of energy--people power. Go win.

References


Klare, Michael T. (2012). The race for what’s left. New York, NY: Metropolitan.



Thursday, October 17, 2013

Moral equivalent of war? No thanks

Recently (by geological standards), early psychologist and philosopher William James wrote (in 1910), that one way to get young men to skip waging war on each other might be to offer them the 'moral equivalent of war,' such as fighting forest fires, mining coal, building tunnels or framing up iron and glass skyscrapers. This essay has been very popular amongst pacifists ever since, but it always makes some of us uneasy in at least two different ways.

First, coal mining is part of what is ruining our land, our water, and our air. James wrote his essay in a different time and mining is not a social good; it's not even an economic good in the net sense.

Second, maybe coal mining and its analogs should be understood as the moral equivalent of war--dangerous and destructive, only 'good' for the elite owner class, if that--but let's not suggest that young people flock to other immoral activities instead of the immorality of war.

It is long past time to stop equating the care and respect we give to veterans of the armed forces--at least those who didn't commit direct war crimes--to acceptance of the morality of war. Any honest and thinking military officer or recruit who has had combat experience would echo Sir Arthur "Bomber" Harris, commander of Britain's strategic bombing campaigns in World War II, who responded to moral criticism of his bombing of civilian neighborhoods in Dresden, Frankfort, Cologne, Hamburg and other German cities by challenging, "Name me one thing that's moral about war."

Just so. The moral equivalent of war is murder and theft, domination and occupation of other people's land. Great. Don't join the military, youth! Join a gang instead! Or how about the Ku Klux Klan? Sign up with the Latin Kings,
the Mafia, the Zetas, the Crips, the Blackstone Rangers, the Aryan Brotherhood, Yakuza or some other branch of the Fun Kids and you can achieve the moral equivalent of war. You may not get GI benefits but you might get access to $millions in drug or weapons money. Think big! Think morally!

Clearly, for those of us who have faith in nonviolence (and this includes but is not limited to pacifists), the social norms that encrust the military like blood-engorged parasites need to be shed, discarded, and we need to start fresh.

Nonviolent conflict intervention is moral. Violence is not. Rather than serve in the military and lose your moral standing, look for moral activities that are robust, challenging, and give you whatever adrenaline rush that combat gives, only without the chance that you are going to kill someone. Try the Peace Corps, AmeriCorps, learn to be an EMT, go to nursing school and work in the emergency room, join a peace team in the Shanti Sena Network, be a fireperson (urban or forest), be a social worker in a poor neighborhood, be a Catholic Worker, work with Peace Brigades International, Nonviolent Peaceforce, Christian Peacemaker Teams, or some other accompaniment or nonviolent interventionary organization. There are many opportunities to help in high risk, exciting ways that lower levels of violence instead of contribute to them, and some of them even pay!

This is about changing how we prepare our youth to feel like they are crucial to our security, our expanded sense of human security that might have them erecting towers and installing wind machines or maintaining them, or perhaps clambering onto rooftops to install solar electric or solar water heating panels. We need to take away the sense of valorizing or sacralizing those youth who feel attracted to holding big weapons and instead honor those who head into danger to help reduce violence and conflict. This means parents and teachers need to rethink and start resisting the old kneejerk practices of bowing before all military veterans and start bowing to those young people who are volunteering to do actual helpful work, actual resource-health-environment saving work. The moral equivalent of war is a social set of bads. We need the social goods, the morality of nonviolence instead. It's time to stop mincing our words and deeds and turn the corner toward a new morality that helps instead of hurts. Our youth will respond brilliantly if we give them half a chance.

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Image, success, and failure


Michael Ashmore, of Hooks, Texas, leans against the White House fence with his confederate flag. He and other demonstrators have walked here after attending a rally at the WWII Memorial to protest its' closing on October, 13, 2013. (Bill O'Leary/The Washington Post, via Getty)

Do we care about who we actually are, what our beliefs are, and about authenticity, or do we care about the image of our campaign or our movement?

Yes. 

If we who promote nonviolence obsess about being certain that we are a leaderless (read anarchical) movement, we will put out images that make us look confused, disorganized, adversarial, and like a failure waiting to flop. Eleanor Clift writes about the increasingly dysfunctional image of the Tea Party that is holding the economy of the US and the world in its self-destructive grip right now. That image includes Confederate flags, racist tweets from the likes of Joe the Plumber ("we need a white president") and a generally total failure of the Republicans to denounce or even distance themselves from such 19th century losing attitudes. 

And yet, so often in the 'progressive' movement we not only see the mirror image of this alienation approach, we even find 'radical' academics who defend 'our' version of this. When I noted two years ago that the Occupy movement had failed to create an image sympathetic to average working Americans in many towns--and cited direct evidence from my own city, Portland, Oregon, where drug use, guns, and other practices were increasingly tolerated by Occupy, the Executive Director of the Peace and Justice Studies Association, Randall Amster, denounced me by name in a War Resisters League publication. Amster is a scholar who has written extensively about homelessness and decided, apparently, to take exception, if not umbrage, at my mention of the natural attraction of free food and some protection from police harassment that had drawn in many homeless to Occupy, but Occupy had failed to provide nonviolent security for its own campers, thus contributing to an increasingly negative image to my fellow Portlanders. One of my students had been very involved and even had a gun pulled on her there. Amster seemed unconcerned about all that and instead focused on the necessity to embrace the entire 99 percent if we wanted the movement to be authentic and presumably radical enough for him, even if part of that 99 percent uses violence. Amster says he isn't saying "anything goes," but he then justifies tolerating all the behaviors that turn off the vast majority of Americans. 

Do the math. If you lose 98 percent because you justify the negative behaviors of the one percent who come ready to commit violence, you effectively protect the other one percent--the owners--from your rapidly disintegrating movement. Really? I mean, you look great in your berets with your soft hands and squishy arms raised in fists, but I'd suggest to my fellow academics that some years on the streets and some years living with the poorest of the poor might be instructive. As the co-founder of two Catholic Worker houses and as a street activist for a few decades I can report that it's not easy to enforce nonviolence, but it's possible. Bullies and explosive personalities can be found amongst both the oppressors and oppressed and everyone knows that. Real nonviolence and effective nonviolence requires standing up to them wherever they try to dominate. It's not always successful (I was not born with the nose I have--police rearranged it for me one thrilling night in my youth, and contributed about 30 stitches all around my eyes whilst they were at it). I've been physically attacked by both sides, police and anarchists. Oh well!

As long as activists and scholars of social movements tolerate such corrosive behavior our justice and peace movements will be easily tarred and dismissed. This backfire works with all violence and threats of violence. We will pay attention to it and grow the backbone required to police ourselves or we will lose by marginalizing ourselves every time. The Tea Party is doing that to the Republicans right now and it's easy to experience schadenfreude as we see them self-immolate. I just wish we could learn those lessons on our side of peace, nonviolence, justice and equality.

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Institutionalizing nonviolence

Like the gradual infusion of mineral crystals into a complex creature until it's fossilized, our institutions can be incrementally converted into a stable and beautiful nonviolent version of what was once institutionalized violence.

Peace historian Kent Shifferd (2011) describes this in four major areas: "international institutions, international law, the sovereign state, and local government" (p. 173).

International institutions in our modern era are indeed a modern invention, though some institutions historically have played that role informally--e.g. the Catholic Church, as it both proselytized and issued papal decisions. Similar efforts by other religions--however successful in the aggregate of conversion, have not combined the success of one sect and the formalized central rule of that sect enough to have the same institutionalized effect that intersected in Catholicism. Most international institutions, however, are modern and most are secular. All--whether governmental or nongovernmental--have an effect on the norms and practices of either violence or nonviolence. All are open to change. The UN already tends toward nonviolence and can be further developed, especially by reforming the Security Council. The worst are military alliances and the worst of those is NATO, once a nearly unused defensive and deterrent alliance and now in the post-Cold War world a swaggering bully arrogant to make violent practice its norm--e.g. Afghanistan, and Libya. Increasing the hold of the nonviolent tendencies in the UN and diminishing the power and reach of NATO are important goals on the nonviolent agenda. These are both possibilities.

International law is relatively new and is evolving toward nonviolence in several ways, and needs prodding and attention in order to continue and accelerate that process. Finally, thanks to Jody Williams and her NGO coalition of global grassroots groups operating in partnership with a select and then increasing number of sovereign states, powerful international law was created by the people power on our planet. This can continue. We could outlaw war profiteering and remove the real driver behind the nominal reasons for war, for example. We could outlaw arms transfers altogether. We the people of Earth have that power if we self-organize toward nonviolence. It has been done from below and that is not easy nor fast, unless we compare it to waiting for the elites to make meaningful moves.

I teach in a program with many international students and many Americans who want to go work internationally to help make peace. This is great. I tend to focus on the students who want to fix America first and I do this for several reasons. One, this is my country, I love it dearly (the country, not the government), and I see that love in some of my students. Two, a citizen of a country has more impact at home than in someone else's country, both legally and culturally, usually. Three, my country has the biggest military budget on Earth, the most military bases on other people's soil, exports the most weaponry to fuel other violence around the world and to prop up dictators, and my country has led the world in invasions of other nations in the past few decades. Finally, Americans live in a democracy and everything done by our government is not only paid for by us but is done in our names. So, I try to have some effect on our sovereign nation-state and encourage others wherever they live to make attempts in their homelands too. All the theories and case studies of nonviolence show that this is the most effective process.

Local governments are the most accessible and directly affect us no matter where we live. Yes, we don't immediately change the world when we change our local governments, but the impacts are obvious to those who are affected right in front of us. From retraining police to promoting neighborhood mediation and much more, our local governments are institutions that we can change.

Creating our own institutions is also done daily in our society and the US is historically a fertile field for this. Some of those institutions have promoted nonviolence powerfully and those need strengthening. Others need to be created. This is important life work, paid and unpaid, part-time or full-time, and always worthy. Literally, there is no work more urgent nor crucial. We can not only work for these civil society institutions, we can support them with the fruits of our labor, both monetarily and in-kind. Find your favorites and give and give. You are doing the work of the generations. Thinking seven generations from now, no one will know my name and it's possible no one will know yours, but together we can give them a chance for a life if we make good decisions right now.

References


Shifferd, Kent D. (2011). From war to peace: A guide to the next hundred years. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Gold in the ground


What about legitimate self defense?

The U.S. has changed dramatically since the 1950s.
--Kent Shifferd (2011, p. 157)

Historian Kent Shifferd cataloged the astonishing number of justice campaigns conducted from 1955-1965 in the South of the US, all nonviolent, mostly completely victorious, and summed up the gains. Lest anyone forget, the South featured segregation in all things, from lunch counters to hospitals, from public transportation to motels. Any black person who stood up to it in any way could be arrested, fired from a job, beaten, and even lynched. It was a morally repugnant society and system. Those who cannot understand what it was like often dismiss the nonviolence of the Civil Rights movement, but it was by far the least costly and most successful approach. Apply the counterfactuals and think it over.
  • What if African Americans had picked up the gun in violent insurgency?
  • What if radical whites had engaged in violence against federal officials who were too slow to intervene and fix the racism and grossly unfair southern state laws and practices?
  • What if African Americans had simply used violent self-defense, meeting fists with fists, guns with guns, bombs with bombs, only in response to attack?
Think each scenario through. Not only would African Americans have been crushed by the overwhelming violence of the system, not only would white allies have been increasingly persecuted and isolated, the vast majority of the American electorate would have retreated from the real questions and would have increasingly been grateful for the thin blue line that protected them from the violence of blacks. The righteousness of the cause would have been quickly buried and the focus would have been security, with all African Americans regarded with increasing suspicion. There never would have been Supreme Court decisions outlawing school segregation or mass transit segregation. There would never have been a Civil Rights Act of 1964 nor a Voting Rights Act of 1965. Segregation might have eventually, begrudgingly, been mitigated somewhat, but the costs would have been prohibitive.

Far too often the historical record is ignored and the perennial questions are considered in the most shallow and short-term fashions. Nonviolence, said one African American from the South who was a participant in the movement, was like finding gold in the ground. Violence is tossing that gold into the trash. We need to learn to pick up that gold and work with it.

References


Shifferd, Kent D. (2011). From war to peace: A guide to the next hundred years. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

Saturday, October 12, 2013

The nuclear deterrent is a racist lie: Mother Nature is displeased

Well, nukes are bad but at least they ended World War II, saved millions of Americans from being killed invading Japan, and kept the peace for 45 years of the Cold War, not to mention how clean nuclear power is.

How many problems can we find with that one sentence full of misinformation, disinformation, and Just Plain Lies?

  • The US could have ended World War II as early as December, 1944, since they had cracked all Japanese codes, intercepted diplomatic communiques acknowledging that the Japanese war council mostly wanted to negotiate a ceasefire and terms of peace, but the US chose to develop the Bomb and to wait for peace until it was used on cities, to scare the imperialistic pants off of the Soviet Union (Thomas & Witts, 1977).
  • Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan--all wars that took millions of lives during the Cold War when it went hot, involving the troops of the Soviet Union, the United States, and/or China (Shifferd, 2011).
  •  During the "Cold" War there were many wars every year--both interstate and civil wars--that were funded and weaponized by one or both superpowers using proxy or surrogate troops. All wars were fought on the soil of nation-states of people of color (except Hungary, 1956), even though the funds and weapons came from the white-majority superpowers.
  • Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, Fukushima--these are just the opening acts of the eco-disaster that nuclear power brings to our biosphere, upon which all life depends.
 Time to review the need for nukes, the alternatives to having them, and the ways we can lower the existential threat to all of life by abolishing them altogether.
Evolve or die--this is the harsh message to us from Mother Nature, who will no longer tolerate our radioactivities, our carbon loading, and our chemical warfare against Her. Our methods of conflict management are the key. We can fight each other forever using nonviolence and we won't offend Mother Nature. And when we learn that indeed, nonviolence is more effective than violence, and produces more democracy and human rights, why oh why would we wait to learn more about it?

References



Brogan, Patrick (1990). The fighting never stopped: A comprehensive guide to world conflict since 1945. New York, NY: Vintage Books.


Shifferd, Kent D. (2011). From war to peace: A guide to the next hundred years. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
 

Thomas, Gordon, and Witts, Max Morgan (1977). Enola Gay.Briarcliff Manor, NY: Stein and Day.