Sunday, July 14, 2024

Dialog across difference #31: Kill them with kindness


There is an official traditional international definition of protection of civilians in armed conflict and it always and inappropriately focuses on who does the protecting rather than focusing on the actual goal, the actual desired outcome (Julian, 2024). That is, it is always viewed as a valiant armed force, such as the UN peacekeepers, keeping the civilians safe from the violent ones on any side of armed conflict. 

A focus for the definition and understanding of the proper concept of civilian protection reveals a far more complex picture, often including unarmed civilians protecting other civilians more effectively than even the UN "Blue Helmets," the so-called "lightly armed" international forces. Presumably, their bullets only make others lightly dead. Indeed, UN peacekeepers rarely shoot, and, in one 2020 incident in the Democratic Republic of Congo, the irony was profound when hundreds attacked the UN building there out of stated anger that the UN peacekeepers were doing little or nothing to protect local civilians from guerrilla forces. The UN peacekeepers shot two of the protesters dead.

While formal organizations explicitly eschewing violent defense of civilians is a relatively modern concept dating to Peace Brigades International and other unarmed civilian protection (UCP) organizations from the 1980s onward, the phenomenon is ancient. From hiding Moses from the infanticide edict of the Pharaoh to hiding Jews in the attic from Nazi predations, civilians have always rallied to protect other civilians. Now, however, this is becoming a sustained and generalized phenomenon, not limited to a particular conflict. 

From Peace Brigades International to Witness for Peace to Christian Peacemaker Teams (now Community Peacemaker Teams) to Muslim Peacemaker Teams to the International Solidarity Movement to Nonviolent Peaceforce to Friends Peacemaker Teams, this concept is being modeled in many ways with generally excellent results. 

References

Julian, R. (2024). Civilians Creating Safe Space: The Role of Unarmed Civilian Peacekeeping in Protection of Civilians. Civil Wars, 26(1), 187–212. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.pdx.edu/10.1080/13698249.2024.2324563

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfoHNI1Nh2Y


Saturday, July 13, 2024

Dialog across difference #30: Doveryai, no proveryai

As the peace movement against nuclear weapons in general and the Euromissiles in particular grew from 1979-1987, leaders were eventually forced to negotiate. They feared each other, to be sure, but they feared their own growing domestic opposition even more. 

In a cross-cultural coup in 1987, Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev negotiated the historic Intermediate-range Nuclear Forces disarmament treaty (which Trump unbelievably destroyed 30 years later). They framed it to their own people wisely as a treaty made not to indicate trust of the enemy, not to show that either caved to the other, but rather that it was in the clear best interests of their own people, on both sides. Literally win-win.

Reagan famously and adroitly credited a Russian maxim for this: doveryai, no proveryai--Trust but verify. 

Getting to Yes authors Roger Fisher, William Ury, and Bruce Patton of the Harvard Negotiation Project note, "Unless you have a good reason to trust somebody, don't" (p. 134).

Reagan made a cross-cultural bow to his enemy by using a phrase from the enemy's own culture, and showed enough humility when using it to note that his pronunciation might be sketchy. In addition, when Gorbachev laughed and said, "You repeat that every time," Reagan made another nod to Russian culture by saying simply, "I like it." 

(Reagan also liked it because it was short, simple, and rhymed.)

Trusting your opponent is not necessary; constructing a verification system is the workaround to the problem of trust. This can not only be done to facilitate good outcomes across cultures, it can be done with enough cross-cultural sensitivity to make it more successful more quickly. 

References

Fisher, Roger; Ury, William; Patton, Bruce (2011). Getting to yes: Negotiating agreement without giving in. (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Penguin. 

Friday, July 12, 2024

Dialog across difference #29: Strike up the band! You herd me!

Social psychologists and political scientists have long researched and documented the varying rates that show the political opinion effects of the bandwagon effect, the spiral of silence, and other herding mechanisms (Farjam & Loxbo, 2024). 

The bandwagon effect is basically the tendency of relatively less informed and non-ideologically committed people to go along with majority opinion. 

The spiral of silence is the phenomenon of those with a minority opinion tending to avoid making that opinion public. 

While neither of these problematic conditions will necessarily alter political outcomes in the short term, they may contribute to increased polarization and to the media indexing that can effectively erase some minority opinions. 

For instance, few polls ask citizens if they wish that the federal government would prioritize education and health care for all over a larger and larger Pentagon budget. This may tend to make such questions increasingly marginalized, even as evidence mounts that other highly successful, prosperous, and egalitarian countries have done just that. 

Over time, then, the calls to cut Pentagon bloat and instead support universal health care and free public higher education are relegated to the outlying margins of public discourse. Fighting this tendency is a complex undertaking, one that will involve innovation, dedication, and long-term commitment. There is no one tactic that will achieve this, nor is there a plan, simple or complex, to do so. Arguably, there is no greater political task at hand. 

References

Farjam, M., & Loxbo, K. (2024). Social conformity or attitude persistence? The bandwagon effect and the spiral of silence in a polarized context. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion & Parties, 34(3), 531–551. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.pdx.edu/10.1080/17457289.2023.2189730

Thursday, July 11, 2024

Dialog across difference #28: Give me a break

In tough talks, especially when disagreement has fueled substantive negotiations that have become rife with questionable tactics, there can be an advantage in simply noting that the contesting environment is beginning to feel toxic and you are going to pause your involvement for the moment (Fisher, Ury & Patton, p. 142). 

This can be especially helpful when one side has been exerting increasing pressure framed as time-urgent. Quick executive decisions may be adaptive in many cases but hurried decisions that feel driven by one side's push to cave are seldom wise decisions. Halting engagement for an undisclosed period can sometimes reset the tone and convince the parties to back off so that the merits become the central focus instead of one party's clamoring need for resolution.

It is frequently noted in discussions about diplomacy that, while all negotiators have home cultures, diplomats develop a culture unto themselves and amongst each other as well. Helping shape that culture by being flexible until you cannot be--by making concessions based on the merits and holding the line when principles are being violated--can help with the sustainable contours of how guard rails can be constructed to help that diplomacy culture keep all parties safer.

Fisher, Roger; Ury, William; Patton, Bruce (2011). Getting to yes: Negotiating agreement without giving in. (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Penguin. 

Wednesday, July 10, 2024

Dialog across difference #27: Golden bridges

In all conflicts in which you hope for a passable outcome, it is wise to keep the golden bridges in mind. 

Sometimes the golden bridge is to a solution you've synthesized that meets more of all parties' objectives than the zero-sum garden variety "choices." 

Sometimes the golden bridge is from Sun Tzu's The Art of War, in which he advocates building a golden bridge over which your enemy can retreat--make your opponent's retreat feel worthy, with zero disrespect or shame attached to the retreat and with other rewards to which you've drawn attention. 

When I've failed to manage my conflicts well, I have failed to use an available golden bridge or I've failed to build one. 

I suspect my failures relate to my absorption of the dysfunctional conflict culture in which we live. I suspect my successes relate to my learning about the methods we are studying in the field of Conflict Transformation. 

I had a conflict today with two professors. I felt misunderstood and ambushed, and worked on golden bridges, and the conflict transformed from destructive to productive and constructive. Here I am in my elder years and still learning and still needing the self-talk necessary to push myself down the proper path. But when I do, it works. The younger you learn this, the more it can become your default response and the less that conflict will impinge on your sense of well-being. 

Tuesday, July 09, 2024

Dialog across difference #26: Dialog lemonade from an overload of lemons

Many places on Earth are being overcome by a flood of refugees from wars, climate chaos, economic privation, and rampant crime--many of the worst lemons of human phenomena. There is also a concomitant rise in nationalism and resultant pressure on minorities to express their own nationalistic tendencies when confronted by the majority becoming more nativist. Causation becomes harder to identify ("They started it!) but the lemons are seemingly popping up everywhere.

The Council of Europe[1] describes it: 

"Our cultural environment is changing quickly and becoming more and more diversified. Cultural diversity is an essential condition of human society, brought about by cross-border migration, the claim of national and other minorities to a distinct cultural identity, the cultural effects of globalisation, the growing interdependence between all world regions and the advances of information and communication media. More and more individuals are living in a “multicultural” normality and have to manage their own multiple cultural affiliations."

What do we do to make lemonade of all these lemons?

Few societies seem interested in cross-cultural dialog until there is destructive cross-cultural conflict; the negative aspects of multicultural societies at times seem to be "necessary" in order to generate possible interest in opening lines of dialog across cultural difference. In some cases, apparently, bad things need to happen in order to help folks be receptive to something prescriptive. Yes, prevention is always best, but seemingly not often practiced. 

With all the challenges of a multicultural environment, the Council of Europe lays out some requisite conditions to embarking on cross-cultural dialog, conditions that dialog facilitators might consider in their own efforts anywhere: 

Based on existing experience, one can propose at least six crucial conditions that must be fulfilled from the very outset, or achieved during the process, conditions that might inform all who seek progress via dialog:

·       Equal dignity of all participants;

·       Voluntary engagement in dialogue;

·       A mindset (on both sides) characterised by openness, curiosity and commitment, and the absence of a desire to “win” the dialogue;

·       A readiness to look at both cultural similarities and differences;

·       A minimum degree of knowledge about the distinguishing features of one’s own and the “other” culture;

·       The ability to find a common language for understanding and respecting cultural differences.



[1] https://www.coe.int/t/dg4/intercultural/concept_EN.asp

Monday, July 08, 2024

Dialog across difference #25: More than a river in Egypt: Denial in ersatz peacebuilding

 "Negative peace," says peace scholar Kent Shifferd, "is the peace the generals get after they win the war."[1]

Negative peace might be said to be the peace in a situation that locks in a power imbalance, often by some version of a gun-to-the-head threat to the losing side: Do not mistake this for peace with free speech, law that applies equally to all, or any sort of equality, much less equity. 

Peaceworkers, peace scholars, and peacebuilding practitioners note many of the aspects of classic negative peace have existed in Sri Lanka since the 2009 victory of the government military over the Tamil Tigers. The administrations in power since then have refused to entertain any examination of alleged war crimes committed by government forces during the war and have essentially excluded external peace professionals from post-war reconciliation efforts in a "context of denial" (Walpita, 2023).

One element of this denial is to stymie local grassroots peace activists in the areas home to the Tamils, obviating the perspectives that might help toward building a sustainable peace as envisioned by many international experts. This is especially pernicious when the defeated armed forces of one ethnic group seemingly become what the ruling party sees as the identity of the populace of that ethnicity, effectively silencing them and virtually guaranteeing a future outbreak of hot conflict again. 

It is hard work to overcome the traumas of war and perhaps hard work to set aside the desires to punish the identity group deemed responsible. We've seen the results in Israel/Palestine, we see them in Sudan, in Congo, and indeed, those concepts scale up and down, from the international, to the aftermath of civil war in some places, domestically in the inability of some who even lose a free and fair election to accept the results, all the way down to workplace and family dynamics. 

Trauma-informed peacebuilding is not easy, can feel unfair, and requires more grace than many can manage. In fact, some trauma is so severe that reconciliation may be exceedingly rare. There are folks in the US who nurse grudges for generations against those who have been enemies, even though none of the actual enemies are living; the end of the US Civil War was officially signed nearly 160 years ago, yet intergenerational retention of grievances in the white culture of the former Confederate states is clearly a political and cultural factor in ongoing political and cultural conflict in the US. 

While reconciliation cannot absolutely efface all trauma as an emotional artifact in opposing identity groups, it can dampen it so effectively that the expressions of the grievances become more and more rare and are seen as less and less valid. Few in the US express open hatred for Japanese because of Pearl Harbor, few talk openly of despising all Germans because of what Nazis did 80 years ago, because the respective governments on both sides worked very hard to achieve reconciliation and strong collaborative economic partnerships.

In sum, the voices, cultural knowledge, and egalitarian participation of all sides in the aftermath of hot conflict are vital if future slippery slopes to destructive conflict are to be avoided. 

Denial is not a strategy; it is not even a decent band-aid on what should be a healing process. 

References

Walpita, S. K. (2023). Context of Denial in the Practice of Local Knowledge during Grassroots Peacebuilding: An Analysis of Grassroots Activists’ Experiences in North and East Sri Lanka. Asian Journal of Peacebuilding, 11(2), 237–256. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.pdx.edu/10.18588/202311.00a348



[1] Dr. Shifferd lecture, Northland College, 1989.

Sunday, July 07, 2024

Dialog across difference #24: We're working on it: Conflict on the job? It's cultural

Like the three generally accepted methods of approaching conflict management in the literature--positional, accommodating, and principled--research into organizational conflict management tends to show that workplaces usually feature one of these approaches as part of their organizational culture (Munduate, Medina & Euwema, 2022).

This can be a challenge to anyone versed in principled negotiation who joins that organization, as employee, manager, or even conflict consultant (mediator).

Openly discussing whatever conflict culture exists in any organization is a first step toward gently steering it away from a "traditional" hierarchy of domination and toward transformative participation. When someone outranks another and therefore assumes the sole right to voice opinion and make decisions, poor outcomes can be expected in most cases. Even many militaries seem to be learning that. 

When I was a little hockey player boy in Minnesota decades ago, my Dad, who skated for the University of Minnesota, was our coach. Amongst other aphorisms, he would tell us when we were losing, "Number one thing to do when we are losing: change something." 

And that is frequently why a malfunctioning organization will bring in a conflict consultant to facilitate, mediate, and introduce initiatives that begin to address an organizational conflict culture with problems. If the owner or boss had all the answers and tended to impart an organizational conflict culture based the search for productive collaboration, no consultant would be particularly necessary.

An organizational structure may be an artifact of decades of tradition and may have served the organization well when all other competing organizations also practiced the norm of domination and hidebound hierarchy. But two factors can change that. 

One, a younger generation of leadership seeks to adapt and evolve. 

Two, the organization is being outcompeted by others who have learned participatory, engaged problem-solving conflict culture. 

"Because we always have" is no longer much of a reason for certain organizational conflict practices. Stepping up the conflict culture can raise morale, elicit better thinking, and generate a successful edge. 

References

Munduate, L., Medina, F. J., & Euwema, M. C. (2022). Mediation: Understanding a Constructive Conflict Management Tool in the Workplace. Revista de Psicologia Del Trabajo y de Las Organizaciones, 38(3), 165–173. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.pdx.edu/10.5093/jwop2022a20

Saturday, July 06, 2024

Dialog across difference #23: Emotional power in conflict


According to Harvard scholars Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton, and Sheila Heen (2023), "While few people are good at detecting factual lies, most of us can determine when someone is distorting, manufacturing, or withholding an emotion" (p. 111).

However, if that emotion is not explained, all too often it leads to defensiveness, irritation, or other unhelpful emotional responses. 

Many decades ago, as a young white man, I married a black woman. Literally from that moment forth, for more than half a century, I have been absolutely obligated to respond to every occasion when racial language was used, most often when there are only white people in the room, and most often in those cases, when only white men were in the room. 

While I began that journey with zero training in communication or conflict management (aside from what we all get from our families), I tried every possible response I could think of except for violence (although in the 1960s, yes, I idiotically threatened violence more than once). I finally found two responses that worked for me every single time. 

One, a variant of, "While you have a First Amendment right to use language like that, I want you to understand that when you do, it hurts my heart."

Two, some permutation of, "You're a better person than that." 

In both cases, my body language or my visible facial expressions may have suggested I now regard them as no more worthy than the lowest pond scum, my language that accompanied my emotional response, rather than striking at their power, gave them even more power. 

Literally, for 55 years, that person who utterly filthy racist language in my presence never did again. I didn't argue with them that they had no choice, instead I ceded all the choice to them. I didn't call them grotesque excuses for human beings, I let them know I could see a better version of them and wanted to see more of that better version.

Emotions are power, but they can take power away from the one wielding them, or they can give power to the one who wields them wisely. They can transmogrify a conflict (make it destructive) or transform a conflict (make it constructive and productive).

Stone, Douglas; Patton, Bruce; Heen, Sheila (2023). Difficult conversations: How to discuss what matters most, 3rd ed. New York, NY: Penguin.

Friday, July 05, 2024

Dialog across difference #22: Race to the bottom


In the documentary Control Room, which looked at Al Jazeera, there is a scene in which one of the Al Jazeera reporters is in conversation with a number of other Al Jazeera personnel. The conversation is fast-paced, in Arabic, obviously about a very emotional, serious matter. 

Suddenly, he starts laughing and the other three look at him like he's lost it. Nothing being said was a laughing matter. One of them demands an explanation. 

"Listen to yourselves," says the fellow who had burst into laughter. "There is nothing in your minds that isn't the fault of Israel. A fire hydrant could burst in Damascus and you'd blame Israel." He continued laughing, just shaking his head. 

When we consider race in the US, similarly, for too many people, ignorance of the facts is no barrier to forming conclusions.

"Yeah," said the Black fellow, "I wasn't accepted into that masters program. Guess they already met their black quota." 

or

"Of course they hired her instead of me," says the white man. "I'm the wrong color and gender."

In terms of heuristics, there is, of course, a kernel of truth in both statements. Racism exists. So does mandated diversity, equity, and inclusion. But to base fast conclusions on these general facts might be ignoring many other salient and more dispositive facts. 

Here's part of the problem: 

·       White men do not have the lived experience of being either Black or a woman.

·       Black people do not have clear methods of differentiating between the background rate of human misfortune and the extra amount of it due to various forms of racism.

Because of these categories of ignorance, anecdotal information can turn into conclusions based on incomplete information. 

Key to managing this is to acknowledge it. 

"You can't possibly make valid assumptions when you do not actually face a white male power structure which has been proven so many times to make decisions based on race and gender."

"You are right. Let's dig into provable facts together so we can address this with conviction."

and

"Well, yes, denying you that position may have been related to DEI bias, or not. Can we work together to get as close to proof as possible and to advocate in unison for justice?"

To combine both assertions and acknowledgements can help in both managing emotional responses to situations where race is a factor and seeking to be partners in advocating for justice if race has resulted in a prejudicial outcome. Either way, the best outcome is for a culturally competent conversation to help obtain a just outcome and some small diminution of race as a confounding factor. 

Thursday, July 04, 2024

Dialog across difference #21: Who is at the table? Taking it to the international feast and famine

When we consider bargaining across cultures and even across national boundaries, what does research help us understand? What are the best negotiating methods?

University of Mississippi political scientist Lauren Ferry (2023) examined cases of creditor-borrower negotiations in which the borrower sought debt restructuring and found that borrower nations chose different modes depending on which creditor nation or nations were part of the process. 

Ferry found that more complex negotiations between multiple creditor nations led to a focus on the creditor nation or nations least likely to agree to more expansive terms. That is due to the accepted norm of consensus, meaning that the creditor nation least prepared to agree to more lenient terms was the linchpin, thus usually tending to make that nation the focus of the debtor nation's negotiating strategy.

In the end, Ferry's research into publicity about and outcomes from such restructuring processes between 1980-2009, showed that the aggregate number of creditor nations at the table is related to tactics and strategies by debtor nations. When the number needed for consensus increases, the bolder and riskier the borrower nation's coercive methods become, all with the aim of bringing the most reluctant creditor nation into some form of agreement.

These negotiations are cross cultural by definition. The findings can help us weigh best practices--can we reduce the number of parties at the table without exposing the outcome to spoiler attacks? Can we modify a default consensus expectation to mitigate a radical reaction tendency? 

While a truly transnational culture of diplomacy and negotiation practices is an ideal, bearing in mind what tendencies are proven to exist can make such complex negotiations more likely to bear fruit and less likely to feature hostile force of various sorts. 

References

Ferry, L. (2023). Getting to yes: The role of creditor coordination in debt restructuring negotiations. International Interactions, 49(1), 31–58. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.pdx.edu/10.1080/03050629.2023.2156996

Wednesday, July 03, 2024

Dialog across difference #20: Cancel canceling

In "How We Win,"* George Lakey helps describe how to build a mass movement. In one interview with young campaign superstar Daniel Hunter, the negativity and counterproductivity of cancel culture is illustrated. Hunter describes his interactions with a young college student who came from a very rural conservative Christian home and community, and Hunter tried to help him see the humanity in others--BIPOC, LGTBQ+--and the young man opened his mind so forthrightly that he wrote a letter to the campus newspaper urging others to also stop dehumanizing. 

Instead, because the young man didn't use up-to-date terminology and expressed himself in ways that his woke classmates found inadequate, they attacked him in the campus paper and on campus radio. 

The young man showed up at Daniel's door, in tears, and said he would never, ever again try to stick up for minorities. 

Of course not. The ones who should have praised him, welcomed him, and guided him instead chose the cancel culture gotcha tack, thus reverse-recruiting an earnest convert by their oafish self-righteousness. 

Cancel cancel culture. Learn to call in, and stop calling out.

*Lakey, George (2018). How we win: A guide to nonviolent direct action campaigning. Brooklyn, NY: Melville House. 

Monday, July 01, 2024

Dialog across difference #19: Assessment

 Jacinta and Troy are a fairly newly married couple who have deepening conflicts that threaten to overwhelm their bonds. Neither understands why this is happening and each is flabbergasted at the behavior of the other. Did they marry too soon? 

Jacinta is starting to think so. She confided in her brother, "I was so infatuated with Troy that I accepted his proposal after knowing him just three months. We've been married barely a year and we are bickering all the time. It feels like we are falling out of love--he has no patience for me any more." 

Troy is indeed starting conflicts with Jacinta more and more frequently. He is seemingly always irritated with her. He finally asked his mother for her advice. 

"It's not my place to give unsolicited advice," his mother said, "but since you asked..."

She went on to tell Troy how she and Troy's father went through a similar patch and finally got some counseling that worked. She told him: 

"Assess Jacinta by asking with the intent to understand, not to judge, and learn more about her culture as you do. Think about how her family and culture of origin made her into the person she is, including the woman you fell in love with."

"Assess yourself by imagining that you are a counselor trying to assess you, given what the counselor can see." 

"Assess Jacinta as if you are a mediator with no prior knowledge of her or you or your marriage but with excellent cultural competencies."

"Assess yourself as if you are Jacinta's brother, primarily knowing their culture. "

"Assess your marriage as if you are a counselor with serious multicultural competencies." 

"Make notes as you do each of these. Then take some serious time to think through your notes and, during that time, do not allow yourself to be triggered by anything Jacinta does or says. Make a list of your own areas of ignorance. Finally, based on the love you want and that you are willing to give, ask Jacinta to join you in as many deeper conversations as necessary so you radically reduce your areas of ignorance."

"Let me know if this works for you two as well as it did for your father and me."


Sunday, June 30, 2024

Dialog across difference #18: Bipolarization disorder

 According to the National Institute of Mental Health: 
"Bipolar disorder (formerly called manic-depressive illness or manic depression) is a mental illness that causes unusual shifts in a person’s mood, energy, activity levels, and concentration."

Yeah. I think we have something far more pervasive and, frankly, serious in our country than just shifts in mood, unless you count rioting and killing security personnel at the nation's capitol building as just an unusual shift in people's mood. I call it our national bipolarization disorder.

This makes those who suffer from it determined to make others suffer. 
Perhaps it will be local election officials, who report unprecedented levels of death threats and harassment from Trump MAGA followers.

It might also manifest as credible threats against any prosecutor, judge, jury member, or court staffer who has the temerity to work on any case that might indicate that Donald Trump is not above the law of the land.

It can come from intimidation, even by armed MAGA followers.

It has even presented as dire threats, for goshsakes, against librarians, some of the most generally appreciated members of our society, when they are found to permit certain books to be held in their library collection, books that might mention or discuss views that MAGA followers don't like.

Of course it's also found in the more quotidian affairs of our daily lives--at work, in the neighborhoods, and in our families. Old friends no longer speak to each other. Workplaces have become hostile environments. Putting the "wrong" political signage in your yard might get your windows busted--both car and home.

Time to fix this, right? How?

Back at the National Institute of Mental Health, the treatment of bipolar disorder is described: 
"Treatment can help many people, including those with the most severe forms of bipolar disorder. An effective treatment plan usually includes a combination of medication and psychotherapy, also called talk therapy."

Medication is out of our layperson's purview. But talk therapy might help. Who is working on it?

Braver Angels is.

They describe themselves, in part, as "the nation's largest grassroots organization uniting red and blue Americans in a working alliance to depolarize America."

You can find a chapter and see if you like their approach. What if they only saved one librarian from getting attacked? What if they only convinced a small handful of MAGA followers to stop threats?

Or what if they help you and your friend engage in dialog across difference without any dehumanization?

Might be one way to treat our national bipolarization disorder.

Thursday, June 27, 2024

Dialog across difference #17: Healthy communication across cultures

Great peer-reviewed research on many aspects of conflict transformation can be found in medical journals. Why is this, when scant pieces like this are found in Political Science or Security Studies journals, for example?

Medicine is a constant learning challenge. Also, it's an economic sector with funding. Since patients and physicians are quite diverse, cultural competency in care becomes a mandate, not just a nice option. Finally, published research is a major help to a career in the medical field. 

For instance, a 2014 Australian conference featured a workshop in cross cultural competencies. A range of skills were studied and demonstrated and the final exercise was for each participant to design their individual learning plan toward strong cross cultural competency in their work. 

This is reminiscent of Anthony Jackson's admonition during Portland Peace Team trainings to use his "grocery store" model--yes, you can see all the various items, but select only what you really want and, in the case of learning, have the bandwidth to work on. Educational theorists point out that andragogy--adult learning--is built best along those lines. Pedagogy--child learning--is far more generalized and inclusive, assuming virtually zero pre-developed knowledge and almost no reasonable discernment about utility of particular knowledge. 

Thus, taking trainings and then constructing a personal plan of further learning to precisely suit individual goals makes excellent sense.


Patel, B. (2015). Communicating across cultures: proceedings of a workshop to assess health literacy and cross-cultural communication skills. Journal of Pharmacy Practice & Research, 45(1), 49–56. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.pdx.edu/10.1002/jppr.1062

Wednesday, June 26, 2024

Dialog across difference #16: From culture war to culture peace

On the application of principled negotiation to a cross-cultural conflict, I am comforted by the cross-cultural work done by Fisher and Ury in particular.* Fisher was a diplomat, working with leaders from around the world, but Ury not only does that, he is by discipline an anthropologist, deeply immersed in knowledge and practice of many cultures around the world. 

Part of the key in understanding cross-cultural conflict work is to take into account the cultural tendencies of all parties but to also understand universal factors. 

For example, a universal factor is that humans almost always require respect. The cross-cultural aspect is then, "How does this culture generally show and receive respect?" It may be by praise that seems odd to someone from another culture, or it may be by seeking out individual discussions--what mediators call a caucus.

It certainly helps when all parties are reassured somehow about intentions and a humility that acknowledges cultural lack of knowledge. For instance, "I want you to know that I never mean any disrespect and I'm grateful for your advice in that regard." Finding ways to remind all parties that your skills are never perfect but your goal is always to preserve everyone's dignity can go further in some cases than trying to show expertise in someone else's cultural practices. 

I ran into this in Italy once when my asthma kicked in badly (this was back in the bad old days when all coffeeshops were thick with smoke and streets were choking with diesel fumes). I practiced my phrases and went into a drugstore and ripped out a really good request in Italian. The pharmacist answered in Italian, probably in a tempo that any native Italian could understand, and my expression of utter confusion was underscored by me reaching into my man-purse for my phrase book. The pharmacist instantly took pity on me and switched to English. He smiled at my efforts and was very kind. I've found this from culture to culture--pretty much everyone appreciates a good try when obviously done with respect for them and their cultural practices. 

This is not to say it is ever necessary to violate your own cultural or personal principles, but you may need to explain them. For instance, I've been a vegetarian for 55 years, all my adult life. I've learned there are ways to make that acceptable to just about anyone in any cultural setting. I've done a fair bit of work with various tribes on issues and have been at many meals. I've learned that one cannot come across as demanding, nor can one appear to be regarding others' practices as subpar philosophically. I've never been demanding nor smug, but I've learned that one can appear to be those ways without any intention to be. So, I will simply make a humble request along the lines of, "My religious beliefs do not permit any meat. Can you help me choose the food that works for that? I'm very grateful for your help." I don't explain my religion, since virtually everyone respects religious beliefs that don't seem arrogant. I don't name my religion since even doing so can appear as if my religion is superior. I leave it at that and virtually all folks--including those who prepared the food with great care and love--are gracious about that. 

In sum, cross-cultural conflict work is complex, but even for those without deep knowledge of others' cultures, it's made much more possible when prefaced by and buttressed by a show of respect, including a humble self-respect.

*Fisher, Roger, & Ury, William (2011). Getting to yes: Negotiating agreement without giving in. (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Penguin. 

Tuesday, June 18, 2024

Dialog across difference #15: Then came the lame blame and shame game

With some extreme exceptions (e.g., sexual abuse of a child, greed-motivated murder), there are a multitude of practical reasons to eschew the all-too-human tendency to blame someone for anything that isn't perfect, or even for something that is an epic fail. 

Stone, Patton & Heen (2023) line some of them up for our consideration:

·       Usually doesn't problem-solve.

·       Limits learning and learning-based adjustments. 

·       Allows all others who contributed in any way to continue contributing to the next iteration of the failure.

·       Can cause the blamed person to take no future risks and achieve few future rewards.

·       Reinforces the zero-sum nature of adversarial conflict, which incentivizes blaming others in order to own no share of the problem.

All these factors and more inform the best facilitators, who generally shift the conversations from finger-pointing to handshaking on promises to collaborate on problem-avoidance as the best problem solution.

References

Stone, Douglas; Patton, Bruce; Heen, Sheila (2023). Difficult conversations: How to discuss what matters most, 3rd ed. New York, NY: Penguin.

Monday, June 17, 2024

Dialog across difference #14: Back to Cold War roots

The Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE) existed during the Cold War to facilitate dialog aiming toward cooperation between rivals rather than simply collaboration amongst like-minded nations (Crump, 2016). The dialog amongst 35 European nations arguably helped avoid a land war or an apocalyptic nuclear war even when some leaders and some circumstances seemed pointed toward that destructive outcome. 

The formulation of the CSCE dialog offered two important features. 

One, that it continually asserted that European security was a multilateral and pan-European phenomenon, linking the security of each nation to an indivisible security for all, not just despite rivalries, but because of them.

Two, that it was process, not a limited goal-oriented endpoint action.

These components can teach us a great deal about using dialog when organizations tend toward rivalry. Emphasizing the mutual interdependence of well-being and the never-ending need for the relational benefits of ongoing dialog can help blunt our human tendencies toward sudden extreme turns toward destructive conflict. 

References

Crump, L. (2016). Forty-five Years of Dialogue Facilitation (1972-2017). Security and Human Rights, 27(3–4), 498–516. https://doi.org/10.1163/18750230-02703017

Sunday, June 16, 2024

Dialog across difference #13: Hungry for understanding

When we facilitate groups, we do better when we attempt to lower barriers to participation and to cross-cultural understanding. Sometimes that cross-cultural work is between groups with different collective identities; sometimes it is done with groups that are a different ethnicity than that of the facilitator; sometimes there are more than one cultural identities of individuals in the same group. 

Indeed, it is likely more rare to facilitate a monocultural group by a facilitator of the same cultural identity, especially in a pluralistic culture. It can feel as if there are too many factors to be able to either succeed or to properly evaluate the facilitation experience. 

At the very least, then, facilitators might need a checklist to attempt to pre-arrange as many factors as possible toward a successful experience. 

One factor in one five-week cross-cultural facilitation exercise of different racial-identified middle schoolers revealed on factor not commonly discussed in analysis of variables was an observation made nearly at the conclusion of the exercise, that the groups of students in the discussions about racial identity were participating right before lunch (Candelari & Huber, 2002). 

In their evaluations of the experience, the researchers noted that levels of hunger--possibly particularly for the adolescents involved--and accompanying anxiety, anticipation, and growing body signals--were unhelpful in cultivating as much focus and engagement as might have happened if another time or another method (provision of healthy snacks) mitigated that distraction. 

The best facilitators may be assisted by a checklist to make all conditions for a successful group process as conducive to that outcome as possible.

References

Candelario, N., & Huber, H. (2002). A School-Based Group Experience on Racial Identity and Race Relations. Smith College Studies in Social Work, 73(1), 51–72.