Saturday, May 11, 2024

Deëscalation tip #48

 What if you are threatened with a weapon?

The Crisis Prevention Institute says: 

"If the person senses that you're losing control, their behavior will most likely escalate. So keep the following tips in mind until professional assistance arrives:

  • Take threats seriously. If anyone communicates any possibility of using a weapon against you, assume that they have one even if you can't see it or verify it immediately.
  • Step back. Try to negotiate permission to take at least three steps away from the individual. If allowed, the increased distance can reduce both anxiety and weapon accuracy.
  • Avoid reaching for the weapon. Attempting to disarm a person with a weapon can be extremely dangerous.
  • Focus on the individual rather than the weapon. When threatened, we tend to focus on the weapon. Shifting your focus to the individual will remind you that the real danger is not in the weapon itself, but in the aggressor's behavior.
  • Negotiate. Make basic requests to solicit affirmative responses. The more the aggressor says "yes" to you, the less likely the weapon is to be used against you.
  • Buy time. Time is an asset. The longer you can talk to an aggressive individual, the less likely it is that the weapon will be used."

Perhaps most important of all, remember that any previous interactions will play a critical role in the outcome of an incident involving a weapon. Not all gun violence involves people who know each other. And no one can guarantee that if you treat people well they will never attempt to use a weapon against you. But if you consistently interact with people in a considerate and respectful manner, you are less likely to become a target of violence.

Friday, May 10, 2024

Deëscalation tip #47

It was at the Portland Oregon building permit and records building, but it was the City Council taking testimony on some issues. We had been invited to provide a peace presence.

She was yelling and she clambered over the railing and onto a beam. I made a beeline for her. She came back, still yelling at the uniformed security guards. She sat down for a second, still loudly proclaiming that she had a right to smudge. First two, then three security guards hovered over her. I stepped in-between, in front of her and looked at her. 

"I like your earrings," I said, "and especially your brim." She was identifying as Native American and I wanted to acknowledge that. 

She glanced at me, apparently prepared to take it as sarcasm, as a veiled racial insult. 

"Thanks," she said, quietly. 

She got up and bolted. Another fellow was darting around. I refocused, on him. Eventually, one floor down, I caught up to her. By this time, four security guards were in a half-circle around her, but she was more or less deëscalated. 

That was because Anthony, another member of our Portland Peace Team, was with her. Anthony is a professional conflict transformation specialist, both in mediation and ombuds roles, and has been for approximately 20 years. Anthony was telling her how he had visited both Canada and Alaska and had found the dominant cultures there much more respectful of inherent Native rights. 

We clearly had the advantage when it came to deëscalating because our methods were not in line with official policies. We could take the time, whereas armed security were instructed far more to focus on establishing dominance and moving it quickly to close-out. We stayed with her for as long as it took, and it took relatively little time because we showed what Kwame Christian calls compassionate curiosity. She and I made eye contact and she started to cry. She had been yelling. We tag-teamed some compassion and some listening and it hit her and moved her. 

When you see a dysfunctional failed deëscalation, you may be the one to get it right. 

Thursday, May 09, 2024

Deëscalation tip #46

Deëscalation at a dog park?

Here is where I turn to others without any personal expertise. I am not a dog owner and my nonviolence has been working well on humans, but dogs? I am not the dog whisperer.

Here is part of what some dog experts say: 

"Don't use your body; use aversive tools.
You should always bring emergency tools to the dog park, just in case. They will prevent injury to both dogs and people. People are known to get severe and damaging bites by trying to break up dog fights with their hands and bodies, as the dog may not realize they are biting a human, and may not inhibit their bites as they normally would if they feel they’re being attacked, or think they are biting another dog. Dogs have protective coats, whereas humans just have skin, so the same bite can be much more damaging to a person than another dog. ​

Try tools in the following order: clapping, using a strong voice (not yelling), water/spray bottles, insert chairs or boards or other furniture, spray with a hose or dump a bucket of water, citronella spray, or set off an air horn in the faces of the fighting dogs."

OK, I confess: I laughed to myself when I thought of using the same methods with scrapping humans. Bucket brigade! Deploy citronella! Pass the lawn furniture! Clap everyone! Where's my air horn?

Wednesday, May 08, 2024

Deëscalation tip #45

 "Meet animosity with curiosity." 

"Taking a couple of long deep breaths--in and out--helps calm the nervous system. Breathing decreases the level of cortisol, the stress hormone, in our bodies and lowers our heart rate and blood pressure. In short, breathing can change our state of mind."                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        

Bill Ury, 2024, p. 60


Tuesday, May 07, 2024

Deëscalation tip #44

Paying attention to deëscalation in key moments of rising conflict can literally be a matter of life and death. I was just an expert witness on it in a civil case and helped convince a jury of 12 regular folks that police, in particular, have a high bar in this regard, by law and by good sense. 

The case involved an unfortunately familiar 911 call, dispatch of emergency workers, and mental health crisis conflict exacerbated by use of meth. 

One officer on the scene was primary, or contact officer. He was young, and was following best practices, establishing a rapport with the fellow--who had himself called 911 for help--but the second officer, a big man, fingered his weapon and then just bulled in and started barking commands. The fellow, who had been sitting down as requested by the first officer, stood up and pulled out a screwdriver and the cop shot him dead.

The jury got to see that footage. It didn't take much to convince them of the obvious, that one cop's work to deëscalate was ruined permanently by another's failure. That shooting might have generated no big notice years ago, but deëscalation efforts are expected now, sometimes by law. And while this shooter was cleared criminally by a grand jury, the bar is different in a civil case. Instead of "beyond a reasonable doubt," it's "preponderance of the evidence," in other words, was the plaintiff's case made so that a jury felt convinced that at least 51 percent of the case was made?

We convinced the jury and they awarded a $million. Deëscalation counts. https://www.oregonlive.com/crime/2024/05/jury-awards-1m-to-family-of-suicidal-man-fatally-shot-by-portland-police-in-2021.html


Monday, May 06, 2024

Deëscalation tip #43

 More on bystander intervention: 

  • Distract everyone in whatever fashion comes to mind.
  • Delegate--suggest to another that they do something to assist.
  • Document--but only as an ancillary tactic after you determine someone is doing something directly.
  • Delay--if you miss the chance to intervene, at least comfort the targeted person afterward.
  • Direct--if you are confident in doing so, confront the harasser and strongly request that they stop. This is the riskiest and after you say something briefly, turn your attention to the targeted person to ask what they need, as opposed to getting into an argument with the abuser.
Note: there are many YouTube vids on bystander intervention that are not particularly helpful, and can place the intervenor in serious danger. Use caution in following such advice.

Sunday, May 05, 2024

Deëscalation tip #42

When operating with a peace team, meeting aggression is sometimes best managed by surrounding the target of the aggression, often completely ignoring the attacker. Facing the targeted person without coming off as saviors, but rather just as friends, is often most adaptive. Asking the targeted person what might make them feel the best is often the best approach, unless they are so overwhelmed they can't offer much coherence. There are many comments and questions in the moment, including but not limited to: 

  • Hi friend, how are you?
  • Hi, can we help? 
  • Would you like us to walk away with you?
  • If you like, we can stay with you until you feel safe.
  • We are not meaning to interfere if you prefer we walk away. 
If there has literally been a physical assault, do not repeat NOT call 911 unless the person specifically asks for that or agrees with it. Perfectly innocent people have deeper fear of armed agents of the state than they do of random aggressors. 

Obviously, if a person has been grievously wounded or if there are gunshots, everything changes. A 911 call is directed specifically by 911 operators and dispatchers. Some will not result in armed agents responding and some will. 

For instance, if someone is being verbally abused and it precipitates a heart attack, and you legitimately call 911 for the heart attack, you may or may not wish to not mention the verbal aggression that seemed to trigger it. This is highly situational. It's one reason we on our team say that we teach a standard method used by deëscalation experts around the world, but in the real world of the streets it's an art and each person becomes a unique artist.

Saturday, May 04, 2024

Deëscalation tip #41

Should police waste time trying to de people on drugs? When 911 calls are so frequent, should police waste time trying to deëscalate people who claim to be suicidal?

Well, maybe. It sure would have saved the life of one 40-year-old fellow in my town. A bullish cop rushed in, started issuing commands, and the person having a mental health issue was overwhelmed, lost his ability to think straight, and stood up to confront the cop, who then shot him dead.

I testified in court as a deëscalation expert and critiqued the police officer's approach. The jury agreed and awarded more than a $million to the family of the shot guy.

The same police force in my town, on at least a couple of occasions this year, took hours to eventually deëscalate someone intent on suicide. Was it better to "waste" time instead of wasting a life? 

There are no guarantees with deëscalation except a guarantee that a person committed to it will not be adding to the level of violence and loss in the world.


Friday, May 03, 2024

Deëscalation tip #40

We can easily find a great deal of advice for police on how they should deëscalate, but where is the advice on how we can deëscalate the police? When they go bonkers they hurt people with a great deal of "qualified immunity" to pad them, legally, so they have little or no "window of exposure." 

On the Portland Peace Team, we deëscalate police at demonstrations by thanking them for not hurting protesters, or resisters. We remind them that they are doing well in public opinion and will continue to do so if they don't hurt people. If protestes start chanting inadvisable messages such as "All cops are bastards! All cops are bastards!" we apologize and thank them for their ability to see the trauma behind such chants. 

Will it always work? HTTFN (Hell To The F__k No). Almost nothing always works. But when it does, what if we "only" save one young one from getting smashed by a police baton? What if we "only" save one young Black woman from getting beaten or pepper sprayed? For some of us, that is worth it.

Wednesday, May 01, 2024

Deëscalation tip #39

 Can entire nations be deëscalated?

Yes, but the key is to understand both the limits and transformative possibilities of leadership. Wait! you say...isn't our evolving culture supposed to do away with leadership so that everyone is free and equal?

No. Not if you wish to move ahead with the transformations we need out of destructive conflict into constructive conflict. As trainer and nonviolence author Rivera Sun terms it, we need "leaderful" movements.

The key is what sort of leaders? In the field of conflict transformation we note that if someone benefits financially, in status, or in power from the eruption or continuation of destructive conflict, they are part of the conflict industry and should never be in leadership positions. 

When the "champion" of an identity group or nation refuses to meet with anyone from the "enemy," and successfully portrays that as being the fighting leader needed, that person is a dysfunctional leader if the desire is more peace, more progress, less destruction. 

Choosing a leader or group of leaders who are trying for transformation instead of power, status, or wealth, is the track toward deëscalation of destructive conflict and that can scale up or down, from a small group to a nation. 

Sunday, April 28, 2024

Deëscalation tip #38

What about deëscalating children? One expert notes that strategies are somewhat different as the child ages up from toddler to pre-teen to teen. Our expressions and tone are as important as actual words. When we are calm in the face of rager kids, and when we exude empathy in a screaming environment, our deëscalation is quicker, easier, and may even stretch out the times between meltdowns.

Saturday, April 27, 2024

Deëscalation tip #37

Deëscalation possibilities can be improved if it seems practical to invite the escalated party to a more private setting. This is not always situationally doable--e.g., you are in the midst of a crowd of thousands and no path to privacy is in sight--nor is it always advisable--e.g., you are personally targeted and credibly threatened by a person clearly capable of violence. But when it is more readily available, a quieter environment without distractions or an audience can begin to achieve a less escalated status for your escalated person. This is part of the art of deëscalation, to account for unique scenarios, threat levels, and capacities.

Friday, April 26, 2024

Deëscalation tip #36

 Peace teams of unarmed, nonviolent peaceworkers have a very good track record of violence reduction and deëscalation, even in hot conflict zones. In the US, our "mother ship" is the Meta Peace Team, based in Michigan. They have worked around the world and have helped create dozens of new peace teams elsewhere. They offer special trainings--either in Michigan or they will travel to do peace team trainings elsewhere. https://www.metapeaceteam.org/

Thursday, April 25, 2024

Deëscalation tip #35

When corkers (bike riders tasked with halting traffic while an event passes an intersection) are out trying to keep riders, marchers, walkers, or activists safe at intersections, they can practice deëscalation--or at the very least avoid escalating drivers who are inconvenienced by the corkers temporarily blocking the intersection. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I_2zlKRxutE

Wednesday, April 24, 2024

Deëscalation tip #34

 Learning about both the theory and practice of adaptive conflict transformation can help us become smarter and more effective conflict workers--but only if we are seriously honest with ourselves. 

·       Do I talk over others in my eagerness to win arguments?

·       Do I assume the fundamental attribution error (my mistakes are excusable and due to circumstances; the mistakes of others are due to their flawed nature)?

·       Am I compassionate or judgmental?

·       Do I avoid conflict at all costs?

·       Am I a doormat, submissive and compliant even when I feel I am allowing someone to dominate me?

·       Am I dismissive of the hurt someone else might feel?

All these questions and more, informed by the scholars and practitioners who have proven concepts and techniques, can help us overcome the weaknesses that hold us back from increasing success in managing conflict. Honest self-assessment and self-talk are how we learn, no matter how slowly, to best manage the inevitable conflict coming our way. 

Practicing the listening necessary to effective deëscalation is improved by our rigorous self-awareness and willingness to move out of our comfort zone.

Tuesday, April 23, 2024

Deëscalation tip #33

Creating new neural pathways can change our "natural" responses. 

Meeting an escalated person's unreasonable demands, accusations, and hostility with respectful listening may feel quite unnatural, even as our default reactions might be internally escalated and burning to meet aggression with aggression. The focus on deëscalation, as unnatural as it may feel, can help us overcome that default wiring. 

But only by practice can we slowly make that new neural pathway as well used and ultimately more easily taken than the old reactionary pathway. This is how we incrementally develop a new natural response, a new default pathway to manage escalated behavior--ours and theirs. We can speed up that adaptive process by much more practice. 

Monday, April 22, 2024

Deëscalation tip #32

Be aware of the fundamental negative attribution error, which is our human tendency to assume that anything we don't appreciate about another person is due to their character flaws, while anything we do that might not be right or good is due to unfortunate circumstances. No excuses for The Other; always an excuse for ourselves. Knowing that this is a natural human mistake can help us activate more compassion and less judgmentalism, which is so key to deëscalation. 

Sunday, April 21, 2024

Deëscalation tip #31

Don't interrupt. Be sensitive to what the escalated person feels is interruption. Interrupting can be interpreted as disrespectful, or as an attempt by you to dominate or dismiss their urgent concerns. If you are nodding to express understanding, monitor how your responses, even your nonverbals, are being received and interpreted: 

  • Smiling is generally good, but alter your expression if it seems like your smile is being interpreted as mocking.
  • Nodding is generally good, but alter it somehow if it seems like it's being interpreted as an effort to get them to hurry up and finish so you can respond. 
  • Empathic eye contact is good, but alter it if it seems like it's being interpreted as a challenge.
Your own self-talk should include a reminder that you want to indicate that you are listening to understand, not to judge or rebut. Every scenario is unique; the deëscalation tradecraft is both conceptual and pro forma template. You are unique. Your escalated person is unique. The context is unique. Therefore, unlike some exact unchangeable practices, perhaps like CPR, deëscalation is more of a conceptually-informed art and you, therefore, take the concepts and the techniques and use them in creating your own situational art. You are the artist.

Saturday, April 20, 2024

Deëscalation tip #30

Work in teams. If you are already operating with at least one other, great. If not, try to recruit. Do not hesitate to be assertive with bystanders. "Please don't interfere, my friend." "If you can, please find a drink of water for him." "Kindly show compassion and lower your voice, please." "Let's put a hold on the debate for a minute, please, and see if we can make progress together." "There's time to discuss the fine points a bit later, once we can all hear each other." "Understood. Can we put a pin in that and focus on emotional care for a minute?

Create a team on the fly if necessary. Do not fear leadership, just stress humility as you engage assertively. 

Friday, April 19, 2024

Deëscalation tip #29

Leslie Gregory, Portland Peace Team member/trainer and water safety expert: 
Use the same precautionary principle as learning to lifeguard: Approach deëscalation as you would a water rescue: Do not create two victims. Stay safe even as you help another back to safety. 

Thursday, April 18, 2024

Deëscalation tip #28

No judgment, much empathy. A person who is escalated often feels shamed or disrespected. Seeming judgmental can heighten that sense of feeling violated and dismissed. Inquiring with empathy does not equal agreement or support of destructive action. Instead, it simply shows a willingness to hear the reasoning behind the reactions of the escalated person.

Wednesday, April 17, 2024

Deëscalation tip #27: Braver Angels

More and more, many who work to deëscalate conflict are proposing ways to "predeëscalate." How do we change the conditions so that escalation is less frequent, or less intense? How do we anticipate the possible escalatory situations and get ahead of that dangerous curve? Initiating community conversations can help, especially if the invitation to do so includes groundrules that comfort others who are wary and weary of biting, bitter exhanges. This sort of work is happening intentionally now, with organizations such as Braver Angels, a network of local groups devoted to community well being through depolarizing dialog. 

We can do this. We can get our culture back. We can return to disagreement without being disagreeable. It takes involvement by good-hearted, sincere people determined to overcome the dangerous allure of hate and objectification. 

Tuesday, April 16, 2024

Deëscalation tip #26

When an escalated individual is in a crowded space, one person should attempt to deëscalate while another clears an exit path for the person. If a person suddenly decides "enough!" and turns to leave, only to be blocked by the crowd, that is a situation that can lead straight back to escalated emotions and actions. 

That is sometimes when you can see a weapon appear as the person boomerangs from the tentative deëscalated state back to even more elevated escalatory behaviors. A line of sight to the exit (the door or a far less crowded area) is the job of the second member of a peace team--whether that's an official peace team or a simple ad hoc momentary collaboration. 

We were taught this by the late Genny Nelson, founder of Sisters of the Road Cafe, a place for street people to eat a cheap nourishing meal, and a place frequently extremely crowded. Genny reminds me of the best eulogy I've ever read--that of Philip Noel-Baker made for Gandhi: "His greatest achievements are yet to come." Genny changed street culture in Portland and she planted the seeds of nonviolence that can still sprout and flourish. 

Monday, April 15, 2024

Deëscalation tip #25

Don't make the escalated person feel ganged up on. One person at a time should be in contact with the escalated individual. One other may be there, silent, looking unimposing, looking interested but quiet, a bit further away. Surrounding an escalated person, even with silent members, can escalate the person. With enough such surrounded attention, the lone escalated person may lose ratioanal abilities, even without any spoken content. This can lead to irrational action, fatal under some unfortunate circumstances. 

Saturday, April 13, 2024

Deëscalation tip #24

Be aware of your body language if you hope to deëscalate someone. Avoid direct facing, try not to stand with arms folded in a domineer fashion across your chest, keep hands open and visible, and even try to avoid sunglasses or any other appearance of stealth, dominance, or imperiousness. Smile gently. Look like you are listening.

Friday, April 12, 2024

Deëscalation tip #23

Deëscalation experts remind us to be aware of the "amygdala hijack," that is, the sudden dominance of the most primitive part of our brain when we feel suddenly threatened. It perhaps allows us to instantly avoid a mortal threat, such as an obviously enraged man suddenly lunging at us with a knife, but it can also shut down our prefrontal cortex, the portion of our brain most recently evolved into a logical, complex analytical human executive area. When we evade and avoid that amygdala hijack we can help others do the same. As always, deëscalating anyone else is accomplished by first deëscalating ourselves.

Thursday, April 11, 2024

Deëscalation tip #22

Experiencing emotional outbursts from others is disconcerting for most of us. We tend to wonder a couple of things: 1) What did I do to deserve this and does this person hate me? and 2) How can I fix this, either by showing my empathy and figuring out how to fix it or by responding with my own outburst, thus establishing either dominance or such discomfort that the person won't do this again?

Conflict experts Bill Ury and Roger Fisher really try to help us understand that being the calm one is how the other person might tend to also become calm. Regarding an emotional outburst as a signal that the person is feeling radically misunderstood or completely unheard can help us self-regulate into the sort of probing response that can not only serve to deëscalate another but it can help us in our search to identify the other's interests. The emotional outburst is often a restatement of position, opening it to a logical question, "Okay, understood, and help me learn more about why you feel strongly about this." You are acknowledging the strong feeling, not agreeing with it, and in fact, since you seek an explanation, you show you are not buying the position, but since you ask, perhaps you could, if you get a logical, reasonable explanation. This helps the person feel heard, something so emotionally necessary that productive conflict management cannot continue without that minimal element. 

By showing genuine curiosity you also refrain from presenting yourself as The Fixer, which may be offered with excellent intentions but is often received as, "Now they think they can control me, even though they clearly don't understand what the hell I've been trying to say."

Reference

Fisher, Roger and William Ury (2011). Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement without Giving In (3rd ed.). NYC: Penguin. 

Wednesday, April 10, 2024

Deëscalation tip #21

 Listen with humility. When you are actively listening, you are paraphrasing without assumptions. For instance, "Thanks for helping me understand your thinking. Correct me if I'm wrong. What I hear you saying is..."

Tuesday, April 09, 2024

Deëscalation tip #20

 Some 30 years ago, Neil Katz and Kevin McNulty wrote about one sort of listening that can be used to deëscalate: 

"Reflective listening is a special type of listening that involves paying respectful attention to the content and feeling expressed in another persons’ communication. Reflective listening is hearing and understanding, and then letting the other know that he or she is being heard and understood. It requires responding actively to another while keeping your attention focused completely on the speaker. In reflective listening, you do not offer your perspective by carefully keep the focus on the other’s need or problem. Thus reflective listening consists of a step beyond what is normally thought of as listening:

1. Hearing and understanding what the other person is communicating through words and 'body language' to the best of your ability.

2. Responding to the other person by reflecting the thoughts and feelings you heard in his or her words, tone of voice, body posture, and gestures."

Monday, April 08, 2024

Deëscalation tip #19

Listening with what Kwame Christian calls compassionate curiosity is a path to deëscalation.

Sunday, April 07, 2024

Deëscalation tip #18

How can police get trained to manage escalated people more effectively? Does deëscalation training even help?

Doing or saying things that would tend to derail a maladaptive train of thought should be a tool in the mental belt of any officer. Failure to use that tool is a failure of either police training or police utilization of training. Research is increasingly bearing that out: 

·       Researchers examined 130 police interactions coded for a person in a mental health crisis and found the rates of the use of threats and physical compliance methods leading to injury and death of the subjects were far higher than when supportive police methods were used, e.g., reassurance, sympathy, empathy (Blais & LeClerc, 2023). 

·       Similarly, Engel, et al. (2022), in an empirical study on the Louisville KY police before and after receiving deëscalation training, found that, "Using a stepped‐wedge randomized controlled trial research design, the panel regression results demonstrated statistically significant reductions in use of force incidents (−28.1%), citizen injuries (−26.3%), and officer injuries (−36.0%) in the post‐training period" (p. 199). 

·       Again, Criminologist Li Sian Goh (2021) found a 40 percent reduction in "serious" force use in Camden, New Jersey police overall following de-escalation training, though noting that the findings may not be typical due to several unique situational factors.


References

Blais, E., & Leclerc, B. (2023). A Script Analysis of Successful Police Interventions Involving Individuals in Crisis. Canadian Journal of Criminology & Criminal Justice, 65(3), 92–125. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.pdx.edu/10.3138/cjccj-2023-0018

Engel, R. S., Corsaro, N., Isaza, G. T., & McManus, H. D. (2022). Assessing the impact of de‐escalation training on police behavior: Reducing police use of force in the Louisville, KY Metro Police Department. Criminology & Public Policy, 21(2), 199–233. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9133.12574

Goh, L. S. (2021). Did de‐escalation successfully reduce serious use of force in Camden County, New Jersey? A synthetic control analysis of force outcomes. Criminology & Public Policy, 20(2), 207–241. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9133.12536

Saturday, April 06, 2024

Deëscalation tip #17

 Two things that have no place in deëscalation: debate and argument.

Deëscalation first, then civil discussion, including argument and debate. If the discussion is already civil, no need for deëscalation.

Friday, April 05, 2024

Deëscalation tip #16

 Police are beginning to learn their own version of deëscalation with verbal judo, deëscalation for armed officers. This differs from unarmed deëscalation, but it is certainly a welcome direction. 

Thursday, April 04, 2024

Deëscalation tip #15

 Offered on the 55th anniversary of the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

MLK wrote a letter from Birmingham City Jail in April of 1963, just five years before he was taken from us. That Letter from Birmingham Jail remains canonical in American literature and it contains many lessons for activists today.

King explains the sequence of any campaign: 

"In any nonviolent campaign there are four basic steps: 1) collection of the facts to determine whether injustices are alive; 2) negotiation; 3) self-purification; and 4) direct action."

Note that step 3, self-purification, is what comes immediately before step 4, direct action. My interpretation of step 3 is the preparation internally, both individually and collectively, necessary to maintain nonviolent discipline in the face of any insult, harm, or provocation. King's sequence is battle-tested and the groundtruthing of its efficacy was proven in struggle after struggle in the Civil Rights Movement. 

The role of the peacemaker in social justice direct action is to call everyone to that state of being that King advises, the self-purification in preparation for hot conflict and chaos. I believe MLK would approve of the deëscalation necessary to allow the campaign to escalate, one of the great ironies of successful campaigns. Indeed, the rigorous training developed by Rev. James Lawson that was crucial to the success of campaign after campaign was all about that ability to deëscalate oneself and remain in that state with great discipline. 

Dr. King, we miss you. 

Wednesday, April 03, 2024

Deëscalation tip #14

 William Ury notes in his new book, Possible: How We Survive (and Thrive) in an Age of Conflict, that we have "an innate power available to each of us: to pause with intention and calmly choose the next step" (p. 51).

Monday, April 01, 2024

Deëscalation tip #13

Practice the techniques of deëscalation enough times and they become new neural pathways, new increasingly natural default responses, overcoming old default conflict reactions we were taught by family, friends, and media. This happens easily with some whose conditioning is relatively light, but for most of us it takes a great deal of practice and focus to solidify deëscalation as the strongest, dominant, mental muscle memory.

Sunday, March 31, 2024

Deëscalation tip #12

 Emotions can be thought of as layers, with the most escalated being the top layer that masks the other layers, which often include feeling disrespected, betrayed, fear, grief, and unloved.[1]



[1] Noll, Douglas E. (2017). De-escalate: How to calm an angry person in 90 seconds or less. Hillsboro, OR: Atria.

 

Saturday, March 30, 2024

Deëscalation tip #11

 From William Ury's 2024 book, Possible: How We Survive (and Thrive) in an Age of Conflict: 

"I noticed my anger rising and I remembered a subtle self-regulation technique I had learned just a few months earlier from an Ecuadorian friend when I had been describing to him my work in contentious conflicts. 

'William,' he had counseled me, 'next time you are in a tough place, try pinching the palm of your hand.'" (p. 42)

Ury wrote that, indeed, he was invited to help mediate some conflicts coming to a boil in Hugo Chavez's Venezuela in 2003 and faced an angry Chavez one late night meeting. The palm pinching helped him "go to the balcony," to observe and listen for emotional content rather than become defensive as Chavez ranted. 

Friday, March 29, 2024

Deëscalation tip #10

 "One firm rule in getting someone deëscalated is, Never tell an escalated person to 'Calm down.' It never works. Never. Instead, it escalates them."

--Anthony Jackson, professional mediator and core trainer on the Portland Peace Team

Thursday, March 28, 2024

Deëscalation tip #9

 Deëscalation works most effectively when a calming person understands proxemics (the dynamics of being proximal to another person) and the supportive stance, as explained by workers from the Crisis Prevention Institute.[1]



[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBe4A32fpyI

Wednesday, March 27, 2024

Deëscalation tip #8

 One way to deëscalate is to convince the escalated person that you are feeling empathy for them. To do that, it is helpful to think of their behavior, including affect, volume, and other observables as their emotional data field. As you gather that data you transform into an empathic listener.[1]



[1] Noll, Douglas E. (2017). De-escalate: How to calm an angry person in 90 seconds or less. Hillsboro, OR: Atria.

Tuesday, March 26, 2024

Deëscalation tip #7

 Learning to deescalate folks with mental health challenges is becoming an increasingly common and necessary bank of skills. Here is a 16-minute primer.

Monday, March 25, 2024

Deëscalation tip #6

 People who are escalated cannot hear or understand you until they are convinced that you hear and understand them. 

Sunday, March 24, 2024

Deëscalation tip #5

 When we deëscalate we do so far more by listening than by talking.

Saturday, March 23, 2024

Friday, March 22, 2024

Deëscalation tip #3

I imagine that I am but a conduit of conflict and escalation. It can all pass through me into Mother Earth, who can handle it all, enabling me to stay calm in any conflict storm.

--Pat Adams, long time peace team trainer

Thursday, March 21, 2024

Deēscalation tip #2

The CLARA method of deëscalation is the gold standard for unarmed civilian protection around the world. It stands for Calm and center, Listen, Affirm, Respond, and Add information. 

Resources

https://www.boundlessloveproject.org/news/2020/9/24/the-clara-method-of-de-escalation

Wednesday, March 20, 2024

Deēscalation tip #1

 As one of the founders of the Portland Peace Team, and as someone who continues to practice and study deescalation as effective in strategic nonviolent campaigns, I will offer occasional tips for those who may also wish to deepen their knowledge of this key component of civil resistance. I also hope you'll add to that knowledge by posting your tips in Comments. 

Vernal equinox 2024: 

"Affect labeling: 

  • Ignore the words being spoken.
  • Guess the speaker's emotional experience.
  • Reflect back the emotion and use direct, declarative 'You' statements" (Noll, 2017, p. 21).
I am going to agree and then disagree with Mr. Noll. Do not ignore the words being spoken. Note them even as you also note the likely emotional experience. Then use reflective listening, paraphrasing what you hear but do so with a validity escape hatch--invite them to correct you if you do not seem to get their ideas right. 

Don't use declarative responses. Use gentle interrogatives, eliciting more information and they will likely de-escalate as they find you actually listening.

Resources

Noll, Douglas E. (2017). De-escalate: How to calm an angry person in 90 seconds or less. Hillsboro, OR: Atria.

Tuesday, April 06, 2021

But what if they are attacking your grandmother?

You are advocating for a nonviolent campaign to get something done. Perhaps you would like police to stop shooting unarmed people of color. Or maybe you would like to try to stop a dirty tar sands oil pipeline. Or, for instance, you might be trying to shut down a military base that is shipping troops and weapons to some poor country.

Whatever your issue might be, whatever grievance you hope to remedy, you might find yourself with some irrationally violent opposition. What do you do?

Activists tend to extrapolate from the worst case scenario to everything else.

Hey here comes a pipe bomber at midnight to your home? He’s armed, with bombs, what do you do, just let him? Fast? Sit down? Boycott him? Go on effing strike? Hell no. You call the cops and you get your gun. Protect your family. 

OK. Fair enough. Defend your children by any means at your command. It’s your house. It’s your child. You do what you need to do. I used to own a gun, a bit more than 50 years ago. I get it.

Your home is not your campaign. 

Your campaign, on the other hand, if it bills itself as nonviolent, will take chances and risks and never react with violence under any circumstances. Those who commit to following the code of conduct knowingly commit to taking no violent act, even if it meant suffering horridly. That discipline delivers victories; it is the way of the peace warrior and I’ve seen it up close and personal many times.

It is imperative that we understand the serious difference between the personal and the political, the individual and the collective, the homestead and family versus the movement.

But we hear about the “Deacons of Defense,” armed Black people who protected homes, families, and Civil Rights Movement leaders from late night violence by the Ku Klux Klan. Yes. They did. Great. 

What we do not hear about is the Deacons of Defense marching open-carry alongside Civil Rights activists in Mississippi, which was uncontested in its position as the most violent of all domestic terrorism environments throughout the Civil Rights years. 

Why not? 

Because the leadership knew that armed protectors would engender enough fear in the white communities to shift public opinion away from the movement and toward the thin blue line that protects them. 

Because the leadership knew that their message of simple rights—to sit in any public place, to ride anywhere on the bus, to vote, to buy a home—is a message that will be lost if they resort to violence, even violent self-defense. 

This is why we do nonviolence trainings, to prepare people who are acting in the name of the campaign to maintain nonviolent discipline under all circumstances. Any breach of nonviolent discipline opens the movement to vilification and rejection. When we accept those risks as a member of a campaign, we do not concomitantly volunteer to refuse to defend our children. 

Indeed, there is no better way to defend your child than to convince society to correct policies that threaten your child. 

But let’s stop with the red herrings, the posits of disanalogous situations formulated to permit, if not encourage, violence. It is hurting campaigns now, just as it did in the past. 

Friday, November 13, 2020

Agents sent to harm us

 There is a great deal of speculation these days about the possibility of agents provocateurs, the undercover agents sent to infiltrate social movements by police, sent by ideologues, sent by corporate interests, or by any party opposed to that movement. These agents would not merely spy on groups, they would attempt to destroy them.

How might they do that?

The common understanding of agents provocateurs is that they are sent to promote violence and thus give the police an excuse to crack heads. But that is only one of several functions that such an agent would perform. 

The overarching goal is to neutralize a civil society campaign that wants change, or it wants to protect something--a good law, some policy that favors marginalized identity groups, clean water, etc. There are many ways to attempt that goal, including but not limited to: 

  • provoke violence
  • discredit leaders
  • redirect campaign focus
  • promote internal conflict
  • push irrational views to media in the name of the group
  • influence poor financial management
  • alienate influencers and funders
  • ruin image of coalition
  • commit fraud in the name of the organization
  • create factions that split off
  • start harmful rumors about people or group intentions
  • promote an internal security culture that amplifies paranoia
Of course there are authentic ineffective activists who do all these things too, so it is inappropriate to accuse anyone of being an agent provocateur without absolute proof, but it is helpful to periodically remind everyone in the group that agents provocateurs engage in these actions for a reason--to harm or destroy a movement--and therefore everyone should attempt to avoid these destructive practices. 

Call in your less effective activists, please don't call them out. We need to work to promote the more feminist, nurturing styles of leadership that build an unstoppable mass movement. This is not easy and takes emotional maturity. Tolerate each other's mistakes and our own slips. We can do this but we need to do this together. 

Monday, November 09, 2020

Just give me some truth

 We are witnessing an era when social media has supplanted our normal news for many people, and our natural human tendency to engage in siloes of affinity groups thus amplifies the set of "facts" we tend to receive, and it also tends to deepen our distrust of other points of view. 

For example, I find it hard to accept friend requests from people who espouse hatred of identity groups that have been historically marginalized. Racism turns me off so completely that I choose to ignore friend requests from those whose timeline includes dogwhistle racism. Environmental protection is important to me so I tend to accept friend requests from those who espouse such policies. This often means I am creating a silo for myself in social media that feeds me analysis that confirms my bias against bias, my bias in favor of protecting the environment, etc. 

That silo is fine, frankly, as long as I also get news from a diversity of other sources. I get mainstream stories from credible sources like the Washington Post (which is available to both students and professors for very cheap subscription rates of literally about 18 cents per day), occasional stories from the New Yorker, the New York Times, the Economist, Frontline, and more. I listen to podcasts while I do my daily walk, including some news via comedy by Trevor Noah, but also NPR Politics and Rachel Maddow. This mix can generate news that helps me contextualize what is going on, humanize all sides, and see the validity in whole or in part of views I do not share. I believe millions of Americans do that sort of eclectic information gathering and it helps us make more richly informed decisions. 

Sadly, however, other millions only stick to their silos and this whips them into selective facts, underinformed points of view, and misinformed analysis. It tends to make them more extreme and thus widens the polarization and creates worlds full of "alternative facts," a phrase coined by Trump advisor Kellyanne Conway and one that is indicative of the low respect for the truth characterizing Trump and his people. 

Lying to the public is something politicians and their close advisors have done forever. But the rise of fringe journalism that warps the truth (like Fox News or Alec Jones), along with the concomitant expanse of social media as the primary news source for many, has fed into our post-truth polarization. While it is trickier to stay credibly informed these days, the stakes are too high to avoid it if we hope to keep our democracy and avoid massive public violence.